well im not a total avid fan,just like most people they were a bloody good band,and in my humble opinion i thought George done a fantastic job,so you say what you like as far as im concerned :D now another 1, genesis has reformed with phil collins(so maybe i can go to watch them at last)always regret not seeing them when they done a prince of wales gig,i couldnt afford the ticket,was on the yts then,blimey that makes you feel old :D but we seem to be digressing from the lpg thread,ooopppssss